Why Your Toddler Listens Better to Everyone Except You

why toddlers behave worse with mom

One of the most frustrating things about having a toddler is realizing that the tiny human who seems incapable of listening to anything you say is actually perfectly capable of listening.

Just apparently not to you. Especially when you’re already at your limit. Speaking of that, I shared here how moms can ease the load on their nervous system a little.

I started noticing this sometime after my son became a toddler. At home, the simplest requests could turn into a lengthy discussion. Putting on shoes, coming to the table, getting into the car seat, cleaning up toys — none of these things were impossible, but all of them somehow required far more negotiation than I expected when I imagined parenthood.

Then someone else would ask him to do exactly the same thing.

And he would do it.

Not every time, of course, but often enough to make me wonder what I was doing wrong.

I think one of the less glamorous parts of motherhood is how quickly we turn everything into a reflection of ourselves. Before children, I never spent much time analyzing how another person responded to my requests. Now I can watch a completely normal toddler interaction and somehow end up questioning my entire parenting approach by dinner.

For a while I genuinely thought I must be missing something. Maybe I wasn’t setting clear enough boundaries. Maybe I repeated myself too much. Maybe I was being too flexible. The internet certainly has no shortage of advice for parents whose toddlers don’t listen.

The problem is that none of those explanations fully matched what I was seeing.

Because if my toddler respected other people more than me, then why was I also the person he wanted when he was tired? Why was I the person he looked for when he got hurt? Why was I the one he needed at bedtime even when his dad was sitting right next to him? Why was I the person he followed from room to room all day long?

The more I thought about it, the more I realized that the same child who seemed to ignore me constantly was also the child who trusted me the most.

And I wonder if those two things are connected more than we realize.

As adults, we behave differently around different people. Most of us are more patient with acquaintances than we are with our spouses. We hold ourselves together in public and then come home and complain about our day. We save the messiest version of ourselves for the people we trust the most because they feel safe.

Toddlers don’t know how to do this intentionally, but I think they do something similar.

They spend their entire day learning how the world works. They’re constantly being asked to follow rules, manage big emotions, transition between activities, and navigate situations that would probably overwhelm most adults if we experienced them for the first time too. By the end of the day, they are tired, overstimulated, emotional, and completely out of patience.

And then they come to us.

Not because we’re doing something wrong, but because we’re home.

I know there are experts who explain toddler behavior far better than I ever could, but from my own experience, the days when my child seems most difficult are often the same days when he needs me the most. Those are the days he becomes extra clingy, extra emotional, extra resistant to every request. They are also usually the days when he wants to be carried more, cuddled more, and reassured more.

I don’t think that’s a coincidence.

Of course, understanding this doesn’t magically make it less frustrating. There are still moments when I watch my toddler immediately cooperate with someone else after ignoring me for twenty minutes and think, “Interesting. So you did hear me.”

But I don’t take it as personally as I used to.

Motherhood became a little easier when I stopped viewing every challenging toddler behavior as evidence that I was failing. Sometimes toddlers behave worse with mom because mom is the person they feel safest with. Sometimes the parent getting the hardest version of the child is also the parent receiving the deepest trust.

It’s not a particularly glamorous reward. Most days it looks less like gratitude and more like a small person following you into the bathroom while protesting the lunch they specifically asked for.

But I have a feeling that one day, when my children are older and no longer need me quite so much, I’ll remember these years differently. I’ll probably forget many of the arguments about shoes and snacks and bedtime. What I’ll remember is that for a brief period of their lives, I was their entire safe place.

And honestly, that makes the hard days feel a little lighter.


Discover more from Bananas Mode On

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One response to “Why Your Toddler Listens Better to Everyone Except You”

  1. […] how temporary all of this is helps me breathe through it differently.By the way, I wrote here about what to do when your little cutie doesn’t listen to you at all, and why it happens. […]

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Bananas Mode On

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading